Call Them Back

Marge Fenelon

Marge Fenelon
Catholic wife, mother, author, mentor and parishioner of St. Anthony, Milwaukee

When I first began working on my latest book, "When's God Gonna Call Me Back?," I sent out a request for testimonies from people who had left the Church. I asked them three questions: 1.Why did you leave? 2.What kept you way? 3.What brought you back? As you can imagine, the responses were quite an eye-opener. These brave individuals shared with me some of the most difficult thing they have ever told anyone, and I was both humbled by them and proud of them for their courage.

As I poured over the e-mails, letters, and interview notes, a  recurring thought came to me: Where were the people in the pews? Where were the people in the pews when the dozens and dozens of people I interviewed were leaving the Church? Of the nearly 100 people who responded to my query, only a very few had the experience of someone trying to stop them. Most of the time, they simply walked out the exit door without interference.

Take Jasper for example. Jasper (not his real name) had a relationship with the Catholic Church that came in fits and starts. After his Confirmation, he wandered in and out of the Church; mostly out. At about the age of 30, his conscience began to bother him, and he somehow got the feeling that he needed to receive reconciliation and go back to Mass. One Saturday afternoon, he attempted to go to reconciliation at the nearest Catholic Church. But, he'd been away so long that things had changed and he was confused. He watched the other people waiting there, but still couldn't figure out what to do. So he left, went home, and cried. He never went back.

Now, maybe the people there didn't know that Jasper was having trouble. Or, maybe they did. If we saw someone standing around, looking around, and seemingly not knowing what to do in Church, would we approach him or her and offer assistance? Would we strike up a conversation and offer encouragement?

What if we were at a party or a family gathering and someone began criticizing the Church? Would we do our best to charitably defend her, or would we simply nod our heads and continue listening? What if someone close to us was deciding to leave the Church? Would we try to convince them to stay? Would we see it as our responsibility to lovingly evangelize and re-evangelize those around us?

One thing I noticed while working on "When's God Gonna Call Me Back?," is that folks often think that this is a clergy problem. They convince themselves that the clergy are at fault for people leaving the Church, and they convince themselves that the clergy are responsible for bringing them back. So, they wash their hands of the whole affair and cluck their tongues when they see empty pews on Sunday.

The clergy are responsible, but only in part. The other part belongs to us, and it's a huge part. More often than not, we have direct contact on a day-to-day basis with people who have left or are considering leaving the Church. We have those spontaneous opportunities to offer a word of encouragement, to direct someone who seems confused, to explain a misconception, and to make the faith more inviting to others by living it with joy, enthusiasm, and conviction. Nearly all people who have left and come back to the Church credit their return to a simple invitation from someone they knew. We are the someone they knew.

Marge Fenelon is author of the recently-released "When's God Gonna Call Me Back?" and "When's God Gonna Show Up?" both published by Liguori Publications. Her next book will be released by Our Sunday Visitor in Fall 2011. Visit her website at:

Provide your own feedback

The following required items were not provided or are in the wrong format. Please provide the required responses and submit again:

Blog Disclaimer

The opinions expressed by bloggers and those providing comments do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the Archdiocese of Milwaukee. The Archdiocese of Milwaukee is not responsible for the accuracy of any information supplied in any of the blogs on The webmaster reserves the right to exclude comments deemed to be inappropriate.

  Please enter your name
  Please enter a valid email
Comment Title:
Comment: 250 characters left
  Please enter a comment

Contact Information

Office of Communication
Main Office:414-769-3408
Fax: 414-769-3388

Amy Grau
Communication Director
Office: 414-769-3461

Amy E. Taylor
Associate Communication Director
Office: 414-769-3435

Please wait while we gather your results.

Archived Archmil Blogs

The Elderly Are a Blessing, Not a Burden

Sr. Constance Carolyn Veit, ISP, discusses how the elderly should be seen as a blessing, not a burden.

Abortion and Mental Health: Opening Our Eyes

Vicki Thorn explains how a new study on abortion's effects on a woman's mental health confirms what so many in post abortion counseling already knew.

Destination Marriage … on the Road to Happily Ever After

Lydia LoCoco, director of the Nazareth Project for Marriage and Family Formation, describes her experiences with the adult speaker series, Destination Marriage.

Become the Handmaid of the Lord

Anne Bender discusses the annunciation moments in all of our lives.

Forty Years and Counting

Vicki Thorn describes the blessings of marriage, and the benefits of being friends with family members

Natural Family Planning Awareness Week

Fr. Nathan Reeseman discusses Natural Family Planning Awareness Week and the 43rd anniversary of the papal encyclical Humanae Vitae.

Enjoy Your Faith at Theology-on-Tap

Nicole Fastabend discusses how Theology-on-Tap increases both her faith life and her social life.

“Milwaukee Archdiocesan Catholic Schools: A National Perspective”

Dr. Cepelka gives thanks for Catholic education within the Archdiocese of Milwaukee.

A New Year’s Resolution for 2012

Joe Nettesheim discusses how Catholics, rather than strive for perfection, should pursue the art of forgiveness instead.

Daughter, Your Faith Has Made You Well

Anne Spoerl describes how, even in sorrow, we can all receive the healing touch of Christ.

The Archdiocese of Milwaukee

3501 South Lake Drive
PO Box 070912
Milwaukee, WI 53207-0912
PDF map | Google map

Phone:  (414) 769-3300
Toll-Free: (800) 769-9373
Fax:  (414)  769-3408

Copyright © 2016

In an effort to achieve our goals of transparency and accountability, the Archdiocese of Milwaukee has partnered with EthicsPoint, a third-party company, to administer an online service to report financial misconduct. Read more...

Problems with this page? Contact the webmaster

Use the Contact Us page for access to the central offices.

This site is powered by the Northwoods Titan Content Management System