Radical Individualism

Archbishop Listecki

Most Reverend Jerome E. Listecki
Archbishop of Milwaukee


There’s a phrase that one doesn’t like to hear, and that is “I told you so!”  Two figures in the Church have been prophetic in what they have written, taught and preached to Catholic audiences around the world and especially in the United States. St. John Paul II and Cardinal Francis George warned of the embrace of radical individualism, its consequences and the ideologies created which are contrary to faith and truth.

In the last few weeks, we have been confronted with Bruce Jenner who wishes to be Caitlyn Jenner and accepted as a woman, and a female director of the NAACP, who presents herself as an African American woman (however was born and raised in a Caucasian family). Now, the Milwaukee Art Museum – the Calatrava – accepted a work that fashions a portrait of Pope Emeritus Benedict XVI out of condoms and refers to it as art. What is similar in all these situations, is that they each rely on the notion of “radical individualism” based on personal freedom, that is exercised without license.

Now, I am all for freedom. Americans hold freedom sacred and the Church is for freedom. Remember, Jesus Christ died to make us free. But, freedom is never exercised in a vacuum. Freedom demands responsibility and that is a responsibility to truth, beauty and goodness (sorry, if I’m bringing the Ancient Greeks into the discussion, but it’s hard to ignore the obvious wisdom).

Here’s the rub. In our society, we have characterized “truth” as whatever we want to make of it. Therefore, truth is only accountable to the individual. In that context, Bruce Jenner can be a woman this week, a man next week or a Labrador Retriever the week after. Our NAACP director can be an African-American woman this week, a Native American the next and possibly an Asian, simply because she likes egg rolls. Would the art museum accept works that depicted various political leaders of our state in cow dung (a significant animal for Wisconsin)?  Would they accept art – pick your favorite religious or historical figures – featuring them in various pornographic poses (which has happened in some international publications)?  What about art featuring national or international popular social reconstructionists in a manner that would depict the opposite of what they represented, such as Gandhi sporting an uzi, Lincoln in Klu Klux Klan garb or Hitler with a yarmulke reading the Torah, all in the name of art and beauty? Whose art and whose beauty? I would offer that even if the art museum considered accepting any of the above examples, there would be an extensive public discussion that would take place before any decision would be made.

There are three areas I believe have contributed to this radical individual craziness which is taking place in our society. First, the loss of objective truth: when we lose objective truth, meaning that something is truth apart from assessment, then we lose language and our ability to speak with one another from a common perspective. Is something objectively true apart from what I believe it to be? Every word becomes subject to a person’s individual perspective.

Second, is the loss of natural law, a concept which is mocked by some in the academic circles. How we come to a conclusion of whether something is right or wrong has been traditionally accepted as coming from reason. We can know the good because it is engraved in our hearts. However, when there is no longer a good or an evil and it is only such if I choose it to be, or enough people affirm it, you can see why we exist in this chaotic situation. The good is subjected to the whim of the individual.

Third, is the loss of the sense of God. There are two ways by which we come to the truth through faith and reason. God reveals His plan or will to us. Cardinal George wrote in his book, “The Difference God Makes,” “In the face of triumphant human reason at the end of the nineteenth century, the First Vatican Council taught that faith is not irrational. Ironically, at the end of the twentieth century, the Church is saying that faith must rescue reason from its own self-inflicted wound of skepticism,” and I might add, radical individualism.

We have lost the sense of sacred and in so doing, everything becomes profane and is subjected to our own individual appreciation. I need not remind us all of the recent tragic situation in Charleston S.C, where a young man killed nine people after praying with them for an hour. What sense of God or the sacred could he have possibly had? When we lose our sense of God, we lose our ultimate accountability and the identification that my dignity depends on the respect of the dignity of my brothers and sisters who were made in God’s image.

Some may want me to be more upset at the museum for their callousness – calling for boycotts, suppression of donations or picketing. God, religion and faith have been insulted by others throughout the ages and by autocrats and movements far superior to our little local museum. But, still God rules supreme, the Church is here and will be until the end of time, and faith continues to inform and form.

An artist who claims his or her work is some great social commentary and a museum that accepts it, insults a religious leader of a church, whose charitable outreach through its missionaries and ministers has eased the pain of those who suffer throughout the world, must understand the rejection of this local action by the believers who themselves have been insulted.

Love your enemies, do good to those who might harm you, said Jesus. In the face of ridicule, we’ll continue to do our best to LOVE ONE ANOTHER.

Note: This blog originally appeared as the June 23, 2015 "Love One Another" email sent to Catholics throughout the Archdiocese of Milwaukee by Archbishop Jerome E. Listecki. If you are interested in signing up for these email messages, please click here.

Feedback on this blog

Truths, now and later
Bill Schlise

Discovering truth is a painstaking process. Ideas long held as true have been and will continue to be found to be not quite right or completely wrong. To say something is objectively true seems to me an abdication of the process.

Just Say No!
Mary B. Good

Call Milwaukee Art Museum 414 224 3200 and tell them you are objecting to the display, it offends an entire faith community and request they remove the piece. or join the 14,224 people who have signed the

petition to MOM at CitizensGo.org (page 2)

Our Lord First
Peggy M

Always follow your religion. Catholics know our faith does not change to fit our life style..Our life style should follow our faith. The picture is Offensive and unacceptable in todays society. Controversial is not the appropriate term.

I'm sure Benedict is praying for her
Jennifer N

Another mediocre/bad artist needs to boost her career and google hits so she picks on Catholic leaders. What a shock. I will vote with my feet and not support the museum anymore.

What is Truth?
Richard Barone

Truth is often used in apologetics and is an instant problem for non-believers. "Τί ἐστιν ἀλήθεια?" Pilate asked, and Jesus didn't answer, because He stood as aletheia, an unconcealed, disclosed artwork, not veritas--the hidden cause of untruth.

Imagine the outrage
Rocco Lore

Could you imagine the outrage had it been Condom Muhammad?

What About This Aspect of Individualism?
Joel Gaughan

The Church...has likewise refused to accept, in the practice of "capitalism," individualism and the absolute primacy of the law of the marketplace over human labor.207

Don't we even care?
Jeff Cinealis

Catholics are the only group remaining in America that it is still acceptable to degrade - Is it because we have so many skeletons in the closet - or are we really so Christian we turn the other cheek.

Or.. don't we even care?


Your Grace,

The tone of this piece is not in line with the compassion we must show as Catholics. While accurate in the letter of the Catholic law, it lacks the empathy and compassion we must show with those as troubled as Jenner

Good one Archbishop
J. Dooley

"In our society, we have characterized “truth” as whatever we want to make of it."

Sort of like the Archdiocese characterizing the truth of the sex abuse scandal in whatever fashion they want to make of it.

Radical Irony
Jean Ashworth

Do these comments offer hope that diocesan sexual predators this week won't be next week? No one appreciates irony more than I, and Listecki's references to the "loss of objective truth, ... natural law [and] sense of God" are inspired examples.

Truth will prevail!

Authentic love of self & others comes from observing, upholding and defending truth. We are blessed to have a courageous shepherd leading us during these challenging times of increasing narcissism & individualism. God bless you, Archbishop Listecki!

Love One Another?
Ken Webster

Archbishop, the title of your blog is "Love One Another?" You should re-read your blog criticizing Bruce Jenner, etc. and practice what you preach. Do wonder our Catholic churches are empty. Preach love and forgiveness not hate and judgment.

Heather Schweitzer

God, religion and faith have been insulted by aligning Common Core in our Catholic schools. I implore you your eminence, please reconsider and REMOVE CCSS!! .

Provide your own feedback

The following required items were not provided or are in the wrong format. Please provide the required responses and submit again:

Blog Disclaimer

The opinions expressed by bloggers and those providing comments do not necessarily reflect the opinions of the Archdiocese of Milwaukee. The Archdiocese of Milwaukee is not responsible for the accuracy of any information supplied in any of the blogs on archmil.org. The webmaster reserves the right to exclude comments deemed to be inappropriate.

  Please enter your name
  Please enter a valid email
Comment Title:
Comment: 250 characters left
  Please enter a comment

Contact Information

Office of Communication
Main Office:414-769-3408
Fax: 414-769-3388

Amy Grau
Communication Director
Office: 414-769-3461

Amy E. Taylor
Associate Communication Director
Office: 414-769-3435

Recent Blogs

The Archdiocese of Milwaukee

3501 South Lake Drive
PO Box 070912
Milwaukee, WI 53207-0912
PDF map | Google map

Phone:  (414) 769-3300
Toll-Free: (800) 769-9373
Fax:  (414)  769-3408

Copyright © 2016

In an effort to achieve our goals of transparency and accountability, the Archdiocese of Milwaukee has partnered with EthicsPoint, a third-party company, to administer an online service to report financial misconduct. Read more...

Problems with this page? Contact the webmaster

Use the Contact Us page for access to the central offices.

This site is powered by the Northwoods Titan Content Management System